Click
here to return to RHB Home
The
Idiot Brain – A Neuroscientist Explains What Your Head Is Really
Up
To
by Dean
Burnett, Guardian books, and Faber and Faber Ltd –
2016
“Dedicated
to every
human being with a brain. It’s not an easy thing to put up
with, so well
done.”
A
brief summary of an outstanding book; it is very
well referenced and presented in a delightfully readable but scholarly
way.
****************************************************************
Chapter 1
Mind Controls – How the brain regulates the body, and usually
makes a mess of
things.
Millions
of years ago
the first reptiles on earth had a
primitive brain with the clear and simple purpose of keeping the body
alive by
any means necessary. Humans, with much more complicated cognitive
abilities,
have retained the original primitive brain functions.
The
fundamental
primitive aspects are controlled in the
brainstem and cerebellum – sometimes referred to as the
‘reptile’ brain. The
more advanced abilities of modern humans – consciousness,
attention,
perception, reasoning – are found in the neocortex (Neo equals
‘new’)
It
might be hoped that
the reptile brain and the neocortex
would work together harmoniously, but this doesn’t always follow
– the reptile
brain can dominate and cause all sorts of problems – An example
of the micro-manager
is given in the book.
There
is a long
discussion in the book about how brains
function can cause motion sickness.
Room for
pudding?
The author outlines how there may be conflict between what the signals
from a
full stomach is saying and the message from the brain saying ‘you
must eat some
more because the pudding looks very tasty’.
Sleep.
The reason
that we need to sleep is not fully understood. We know that all animals
sleep
and it has been shown in rats that lack of sleep can slow recovery from
wounds
and also reduce life. It has been shown that sleep facilitates
reduction of
negative emotions. The timing and duration of sleep is determined by
our body’s
circadian rhythms, set by specific internal mechanisms. There is the
Pineal
gland in the brain that regulates our sleep patterns via secretion of a
hormone
known as melatonin, which makes us relaxed and sleepy. The pineal gland
responds to light levels.
Flight or
fight -
has depended of course on biological requirements – sleeping,
eating, moving
and also adopting measures to defend against external threat. The
emotion of
fear alerts us to threat. The fear is felt in the primitive
‘reptile’ midbrain
and the brainstem is set for flight or fight. This sensory information
is
related to the amygdala. The amygdala doesn’t do subtlety; it
sends an urgent
signal to the hypothalamus (directly under the thalamus).
The
hypothalamus
sends a signal to the sympathetic nervous system which communicates
with the
central nervous system – the brain and the spinal cord - causing
considerable automatic
reactions in the body – flight or fight! The sympathetic nervous
system dilates
our pupils to ensure we have more light in our eyes, increases the
heart rate
while shunting blood away from peripheral areas and nonessential organs
and
systems (hence the dry mouth) and pushing blood towards muscles to
ensure we
have the energy for running or fighting.
The fight or
flight response triggers
the adrenaline medulla
producing typical responses: tension, butterflies in the stomach, rapid
breathing and even relaxing of the bowels.
If
it turns out that
the threat is not real, it takes time
for all the alerted body functions to return to normal so that a person
can
remain in a state of extreme tension for quite some time. It also needs
to be
noted that in modern civilisation, real dangers are fairly rare, but
some small
event can trigger a memory of the past danger or horror and the whole
process
of alerting the central nervous system can occur spontaneously with
considerable adverse consequences to the person (Post traumatic stress
syndrome).
Chapter 2
the Gift of Memory or the human memory system and its strange features.
Computers
store memory
in a logical way, unlike the human
brain which makes its own decisions about what’s important and
where and how information
is to be stored.
Short-term
memory
exists for a minute or less. It can be
triggered by some sight or smell that distracts us from what we had
previously
been thinking. In some ways, short-term memory involves thinking and
some
neuroscientists call it ‘working’ memory. Long-term memory
provides the data
for our cognitive thinking. Long-term memory appears to have a huge
capacity
(it stores memories for your whole lifetime); whereas short-term memory
is only
capable of holding about four items.
Short-term
memory
is based on neuronal activity in the dedicated regions in the
pre-frontal
cortex (in the frontal lobe).
Long-term
memory
is stored by new connections of neurones supported by synapses. Thus
when we
want to remember something, we repeat it several times, causing
neurotransmitters (chain squirts of chemicals) to interact with the
membrane of
other neurones establishing synopses that hold the information. This
stored
memory can be recovered in the long-term. The hippocampus is the place
where
the actual encoding happens. People with damaged hippocampus
can’t encode new
memories, while people, such as London taxi drivers, have been shown to
develop
a physically large hippocampus.
New
long-term memory
is encoded in the hippocampus and then slowly moves into the cortex as
additional memory forms behind them. It seems that everything that is
processed
by the hippocampus and stored in the cortex is retained for the rest of
our
lives, but we forget things because we cannot retrieve the memory. Some
memories are easily retrieved because they are stored with a great
degree of
emotional attachment; such as a memory of your wedding day; while
others are
not.
Memory
is often
associated with some particular emotion or
sense of place. For example we may have trouble remembering somebody
until we recollect
where we have seen them before. Similarly something that we learn when
we have
been drinking alcohol we may not be able to remember when we have not
been drinking,
but it will all come flooding back the next time we do have some
alcohol!
Memory can
be
distorted by the brain. This is known as memory bias and it is
often driven
by ego. The brain is not just a simple mechanical organ. It is you! For
years
thinkers have grappled with questions such as does the mind arise from
the
brain? Or is it a separate entity, intrinsically linked to but not
exactly the
same as the brain? What does this mean for free will and our ability to
strive
for higher goals? It is now clearly established that our consciousness
resides
in the brain. Our sense of self and all that goes with it –
memory, language,
emotion, perception and so on – are established by processes in
our brain
Everything
you are,
is a feature of your brain and as such, much of what your brain
does is
dedicated to making you look and feel as good as possible. Amongst
other things
the brain can modify your memories to make you feel better about
yourself. Thus
we get distorted memories. It might be minor things; you believed you
perform
better at sport than you actually did, you believe you caught a large
trout
when in fact you caught a minnow.
False
memories.
The brain can itself, put together recollections of things that
didn’t happen
at all; in addition to this people can implant false memories in our
head merely
by telling us that these things happened. People tend to be very
suggestive to
those they consider to be authoritative figures and, in a court
situation,
depending how the questions are put to a witness, they may have a
different recollection
of what actually happened.
The brain
mechanism can go wrong and
memories can be lost or
distorted. Alzheimer’s disease for example can cause brain damage
and neurofibrillary
tangles may be formed. These tangles can develop throughout the brain
affecting
eventually almost all areas involved in memory.
Stroke,
a
disturbance in the blood supply to the brain can be particularly bad
for memory.
The hippocampus, which requires an uninterrupted supply of nutrients,
can have
this cut-off. Even a brief loss of supply can cause serious memory
problems.
Herpes
simplex,
the virus responsible for cold sores, can occasionally turn very
aggressive and
attacked the hippocampus. This will prevent memories being laid down
during the
period of the attack.
Chapter
3 Fear: Nothing to be scared of - The many
ways in which the brain makes us constantly afraid
In our dim
evolutionary past there were
many physical
threats. The world has changed, but our brains haven’t caught up
yet and can
find many things to fret about. We get sucked
into conspiracy theories, paranoid about things that are technically
possible
but incredibly unlikely and our brains can dream up horrible things in
an
imaginary future. The office of National statistics in the United
Kingdom
reported that one in 10 adults will experience anxiety related disorder
at some
point in their lives.
The arrival
of the
Internet has been a boon to people who want to press conspiracy
theories
and to press fear onto brains ready and willing to swallow up paranoid
imaginings. In a way it is going back to superstitions held before the
‘Age of
Enlightenment’.
Many
of those who
believe in superstitions and conspiracy
theories are insecure, immature individuals, subconsciously yearning
for
parental approval that was not forthcoming as they grew up. However the
author
very firmly points out that this is not always the case. The brain is
always
struggling to establish patterns and reasons for things to happen and
hence
having observed one or two occurrences it will establish its own
beliefs that
may well fly in the face of observed facts. The brain may reject random
events
and assume that everything happens for a ‘reason’,
often referred to as ‘fate’.
The brain
is capable
of developing phobias to almost anything; spiders, open spaces,
confined
spaces and many many other things. One form of phobia is social anxiety
– the
need to have the approval of strangers. This can lead to difficulty in
talking
to a public audience, meeting and mingling in a group such as at a
cocktail
party and even talking on a telephone where one does not get the visual
cues of
a normal face-to-face conversation.
There are
people who
enjoy fear. They take part in risky activities such as bungee
jumping and
they watch horrifyingly violent movies. It seems that this enjoyment is
triggered by a very dense collection of circuits and neural relays deep
in the
brain with numerous links to the more sophisticated regions including
the
hippocampus and the frontal lobes. So it’s a very influential
part of the
brain. When the flight or fight response is triggered by some risky or
violent
experience the body is left in a state where the sensors are alert and
poised
for danger but if the danger doesn’t appear you are left in a
pleasant
situation of an adrenaline rush that gives the brain a feeling of
reward. People
say they feel on a ‘high’ and feel very much
‘alive’.
Criticism
is
something that the brain recognises much more graphically than praise. At
the fundamental neurological level, the potency of criticism may be due
to the
action of the hormone cortisol. Cortisol is released by the brain in
response
to stressful events; it is one of the chemical triggers of the fight or
flight
response and is widely regarded as the cause of all the issues brought
about by
constant stress.
Chapter
4 think
you’re clever do you? – The baffling science of intelligence
Intelligence
is a complex concept. Many
living creatures
have brains controlling their basic functions, but so far as we know
the human
brain is the only one to have created its own philosophy and all sorts
of
technologies. Activity of this type has been defined as intelligence
and so we
have considered ourselves to be an intelligent species. However there
are
varying degrees of intelligence between people. Many measures have been
developed to try and establish the intelligence quota (IQ). It becomes
messy
and complicated because intelligence can be considered to have many
different
branches and IQ tests are many and varied.
In the
1940s to 1960s
two types of intelligence were categorised – fluid intelligence
and
crystallised intelligence. These appear to be useful categorisations.
Fluid
intelligence
is the ability to use recent information, work with it, and apply it to
achieve
a useful outcome. Fluid intelligence involves working memory; the
manipulation
and processing of information. It operates very much in the prefrontal
cortex.
Crystallised
intelligence
is the information stored in long-term memory. It is the information
stored
over your lifetime. This information is distributed widely throughout
the brain
and tends to be resilient enough to withstand the ravages of time. On
the other
hand the prefrontal cortex is a demanding energetic region that needs
to engage
in constant active processing to support fluid intelligence. The
intense
activity tends to give off a lot of waste products such as free
radicals,
energetic particles that are harmful to cells and so, as life goes on,
the
pre-frontal cortex becomes less effective. A person in their 80s will
perform
worse in a fluid intelligence test than they would in their 30s, but
they may
perform equally well in their 80s or 30s for a crystallised test. As a
rather
simplistic example; they will know that a tomato is a fruit, but they
might not
remember that it shouldn’t be added to fruit salad! Many
neuroanatomical
studies and autopsies have shown more age-related decline in the
prefrontal
cortex than other regions of the brain.
It
is clear that people
have different degrees of intelligence depending on their
interests,
upbringing, environment or some underlying bias imparted by subtle
neurological
properties. That is why we get supposedly very smart people doing
things we
would consider stupid if it is outside their field of interest; they
are clever
enough to know better, but they are too focused elsewhere to care.
It
has been observed
that high achievers in many fields persistently
underestimate their
abilities and achievements,
despite having actual evidence of these abilities. For example Albert
Einstein,
towards the end of his life, remarked that the esteem with which his
work was
held made him feel very uneasy. On the other hand, people who are
frequently in
the public eye, such as politicians, may be uninformed about some
topics, but
they are quite happy to firmly state their opinions rather than the
calmer
explanations of trained experts. It has also been shown that if an
opinion is
very firmly and confidently put forward, it is more likely to be
believed then
a hesitant or unsure message delivered by the trained expert. Thus we
tend to
be led by pompous incompetents!
Chapter
5
Did You See
This Chapter Coming? – The haphazard properties of the
brain’s observational
systems.
One feature
of our
mighty brain is the ability to look ‘inwards’. We are
self aware, we can
sense our internal state and our own minds and even assess and study
them.
Introspection and philosophising are prized by many people
We
perceive the rest
of the world by a range of sensors – vision, hearing, taste,
smell and
touch. Signals sent to the brain which constructs detailed
representation of
the environment, but this is not always accurate.
The
olfactory system,
takes signals from small particles that lodge in the nose directly to
the
olfactory bulb to enable the experience of a smell. Certain smells or
odours
can trigger powerful memories of childhood and/or bring about emotional
moods
associated with smells. Taste is one
of our weaker smells and most of the signals that we get from something
on a
pallet is significantly affected by the sense of smell of that object.
Hearing in
touch
are both classified as mechanical sensors, meaning they are activated
by
pressure or physical force. The hair cells in the cochlear are
activated by
specific soundwave frequencies. Touch various in different parts of the
body
and can have different responses in the brain depending on the nature
of the
touch from a gentle stroke by somebody you love, to a rough push by
somebody
you don’t like.
The human
brain
prioritises vision over all of the sensors, but the visual system
boasts an
impressive array of oddities.. The idea that our eyes capture
everything from the
outside world and faithfully relay this to the brain is a far cry from
how
things really work. The retina is a complex layer of photoreceptors -
specialised neurones for detecting light. It has a varied number of
detectors;
only the central part can recognise fine detail (this is named the
fovea) the
rest of the retina gives us only blurry outlines, vague shapes and
colours. The
brain then does a fantastic job in processing this information to give
us sharp
image. The brain does this by rapid eye movement over the field of view
and by
filling in the blurry areas by intelligent guesses. The optical signal
is sent
back to the primary visual cortex; colour information is established by
the
secondary visual cortex which does an impressive job of working out
colour
consistency. For example a red object in bright light would look on the
retina
very different from a red object in dark light, but the secondary
visual cortex
takes the amount of light into account and works out what the colour
ought to
be.
The
brain is also very
effective at working out the world as
three-dimensional. Two eyes of course gives us parallax processing, but
even
with one eye closed the brain can still establish a 3-D image. Not as
good as
with two eyes, but still definitely 3-D.
Paying
attention:
The brain is constantly bombarded with sensory information. How does it
prioritise certain stimuli? Multi-tasking is difficult. A typical human
has one
single active ‘stream’. Attention is mostly directed by the
visual field, but
some sudden input – the sound of a cracking branch above you or
an attacker
noticed at the periphery of your eye – can override your current
task and
divert your attention to the new stimulus.
Chapter
6
Personality:
a testing concept –The complex and confusing properties of
personality.
Everybody
has a
personality. Roughly it’s a combination of an
individual’s interests,
beliefs, loves, hates, ways of thinking and behaving. Historically (and
even
today in some religious groups) there was a belief that the mind and
body were
separate. Personality was considered, not to be held in the brain, but
held in
some mysterious thing called the mind, ‘spirit’ or some
other immaterial
element.
It
has been suggested
that there are five big personality traits:
-
Openness
– willingness to accept a new idea or challenge.
-
Conscientiousness – a
person who is prone to planning, organising and
undertaking tasks
properly.
-
Extrovert
– outgoing, engaging and attention seeking. The inverse is the introvert – quiet, private and
solitary.
-
Agreeableness
– the extent to which behaviour and thinking is affected by the
desire for
social harmony. They agree to do things but they don’t want to be
a bother.
-
Neuroticism
– not anxious to do anything much, but want to explain their
reasons in
exquisite detail.
Recent
studies have
shown some physical difference in
regions of the brain associated with these five personality traits.
However
this work is fragmented and incomplete.
Chapter
7 Group Hug!
– How the brain is influenced by other people.
There
is the classic
argument about what makes a person –
nature or nurture? Genes or environment? Of course both play a part and
the
nurture is very much driven by interaction of a brain with all the
other brains
that it meets. As the brain of a person develops from a baby it is
continually deriving
information from how others think and behave towards them.
Facial
expressions
are a major part of the transmission between people. It is sometimes
claimed
that face and body language represents 90% of communication, but this
will vary
with different people – both the transmitter and receiver! The
visual cortex
has subsections dedicated to processing faces, hence we are very
efficient at
interpreting expressions. The amygdala is highly active when rereading
facial
expressions. Since this region is responsible for processing our own
emotions
it seems that it may well be very effective in processing the emotions
of
another person.
Much of
human culture
is dedicated to forming long-term relationships. It is well known
that when
these breakup, through death or one partner walking away, there is
considerable
grief and physical unhappiness.
Because of
its need
to link with other brains, it is easy for other people to develop
new ideas
in your brain that you strongly accept. The technique often described
as
‘brainwashing’, can be relatively benign, as in the case of
social groups, or
it may be malicious, as in the formation of terrorist groups that can
induce
people to become murderers or suicide bombers. Once in a group there
are some
people who want to control the group and establish themselves as
absolute
leaders, in some cases, forming the group into an angry mob creating
riots and
other disturbances. This can sometimes be observed in sporting crowds.
Chapter
8
When the brain
breaks down… – Mental health problems and how they come
about
The
book so far has
described how the normal brain can lead
us to all sorts of things – it can mess our memories, make us
terrified of
harmless things, mess up our diet, our sleeping, our movement and
convince us
that we are brilliant, when we not. A worrying list!
It
is still more
worrying when the brain is not working
properly. When we have a neurological or mental disorder.
A
neurological
disorder arises from some physical cause such as disruption of the
central
nervous system like damage to the hippocampus causing amnesia. These
things are
awful, but usually have identifiable physical causes (although we
generally
can’t do much about them). Parkinson’s disease is one
well-known neurological
disorder.
Mental
disorders
are abnormalities of thinking, behaviour or feeling and they do not
seem to
have clear ‘physical’ causes.
The
author suggests
that by computer analogy: neurological
disorders are like hardware problems, while mental disorders are
software
problems.
Depression
– Depression
is much more than simply feeling dismal or sad. It may be brought on by
a
series of distressing events – loss of a loved one, loss of job,
failure of
some enterprise or other sad occurrence in one’s life. On the
other hand, some
people develop depression without any obvious cause. A widely held
theory is
that decreased serotonin and other neurotransmitters is the primary
cause of
depression. However there have been recent criticisms. It has been
suggested
that changes in the hypothalamus may reduce neuroplasticity (the
mechanism by
which the brain changes itself!) And this means that the brain is less
adapt at
responding to adverse stimuli and stress. Antidepressants which
increase
neurotransmission often increase neuro plasticity and this may be why
they
work.
Depression is
not logical. Those
affected by it will not
think clearly or rationally and may consider suicide as the way out,
without
considering any of the side effects caused on those loved-ones around
them.
Nervous
break-down.
The situation when a person under extreme stress finds that the brain
cannot
deal with all the tasks thrown at it and it just ‘shuts
down’. The results
experienced very between individuals – some experience bleak
depression; others
crippling anxiety; some even have hallucinations and psychosis.
Drug
addiction –
there is a reward pathway in the brain that is stimulated by particular
pleasures we may enjoy. This is a useful area since by eating food that
we
enjoy we get a reward and so eat more of it for the benefit of our
body.
However as mentioned earlier the brain can overdo this and we eat too
much. It
is worse if we get our reward by taking some drug which directly
targets the
reward system. Having had this reward our brain encourages us to have
more of
it and hence we become addicted. Opiates are powerful analgesics that
suppress
normal levels of pain by stimulating the brain’s endorphin (that
is the natural
painkilling, pleasure inducing neurotransmitters) so the brain responds
by
increasing the potency of our pain detection system and gives us a
blissful
cloud of opium induced pleasure. Unfortunately the opiates altar the
brain
functions, so that higher doses are required to achieve the same
pleasure. Thus
an addicted person takes higher and higher doses and is in considerable
pain if
they try and get off drugs by going ‘cold turkey’.
In
all cases of
addiction the prefrontal cortex area has
reduced activity and so logical control is reduced.
Psychosis
– an
individual’s ability to tell what is real or not is compromised.
They may have
hallucinations (perceiving something that isn’t actually there)
and delusions
(unquestionably believing something that is demonstrably not true).
There are
many conditions described as psychosis, the most common is
schizophrenia. The
person may hear voices or see things that are not real, they may quite
illogically believe that they are some other person (usually a
high-level or
distinguished person). In a normally functioning brain the connections
between
the sensory cortex (observing the real world) and the prefrontal cortex
(decisions and thinking) keep us from mistaking events or entities in
the real
world for our unconscious thoughts or hallucinations. If the
connections
between the two cortex regions becomes broken or degraded, the brain
can’t
distinguish between the real and the imaginary.
Given every
possible
thing that can affect how the brain does things, it’s easy to see
how such
processes might go a bit awry, especially considering how what’s
‘normal’ is
more general-consensus than fundamental fact. It’s amazing how
humans get
anything done, really.
*******************************************************************
The
topics in the book
are elucidated by stories from real life, including stories from the
author’s
own life. The work demonstrates thorough research of the literature,
and every
chapter concludes with a long list of scientific publications and notes.
R
H Brown
3
September 2016